View our previous ratings from 2015 and 2014.
We’re all grateful that Thanksgiving is here, if only because we can turn from one heated discussion that divides America to another equally controversial but seemingly less consequential dinner table topic. Let’s talk NCAA College Football Playoff Rankings.
At your Thanksgiving table, someone—brother or sister, aunt or uncle, grandma or grandpa—will have a vehement opinion about how well the playoff rankings represent, or do not represent, the true competitive position of each team. You know how the argument goes: some conferences are stronger than others, some team schedules are tougher, and some teams are untested or underrated.
If your team isn’t performing well on the field this year, we’d like to offer you this consolation. What matters most for all of these schools is not their football performance but their performance in preparing students for success. That is the consequential discussion.
Fortunately, when it comes to academics, we’ve developed a method at Eduventures that takes into consideration “strength of conference,” “tough schedules,” and“underrated teams.” Our Student Success Ratings assess institutions based on their performance given both institutional characteristics and actual performance over time. In other words, we don’t look for top performers in absolute terms, but for institutions that are doing well given their circumstances. We believe this provides better guidance for the task of improving institutions from the inside out.
Now let’s get to the scores. In the spirit of the NCAA Playoff Rankings, here is how top-ranked public research doctoral universities representing five powerful football conferences perform on student success. Scores vary between 35 and 70 out of a possible 100. The “hash marks” on the chart below represent each institution’s student success score. (For more on the Student Success Ratings Methodology, click here.)
Note: Private institutions Stanford, USC, Boise State, and Western Michigan are excluded from the chart.
Four playoff contenders tied for the top spot in Eduventures Student Success Ratings, scoring 70 out of a possible 100 points and exceeding the national average of 55 in their category. That ties them all for 10th position among all 159 public research/doctoral institutions we rated—more than respectable. Ohio State takes the top spot combining its solid student success score with a #2 NCAA Playoff Ranking. University of Utah, Florida State, and University of Florida are right on the Buckeyes’ heels.